Saturday, March 24, 2007
Location: Piikani Reservation, Alberta
I was recently speaking with my new friend Claire about progress. In my journals I always come down pretty hard on the notion of progress and I usually use the term in a negative context. It’s just the way I see it, or rather, I feel it’s my role to hold up a progress warning sign. I do this because I feel most of the western world has been conditioned to never question ‘progress’, to never think critically about apparent innovation, and to just accept NEW as always IMPROVED.
Walking down the side of a mountain we discussed our individual views on progress, and arrived at the conclusion that progress is usually both subjective and relative.
This discussion has started me thinking about what it is I’m honestly trying to say about progress, and where I’m coming from.
I recognize that much of the innovation of the past hundred and fifty years has in many ways greatly improved our lives. At the same time I’m always interested in the question of how sustainable are these innovations. I would argue that we’ve become progress junkies, addicted to NEW and IMPROVED. This phrase is everywhere, filling grocery store shelves, television sets, and our entire world.
There’s this commercial I’ve caught on television lately… Oven Roasted Potatoes… it begins with a girl washing potatoes at her office desk, cut to: chopping potatoes in a boardroom, cut to: spicing potatoes while driving home. The slogan comes in “Tired of working all day for perfect oven-roasted potatoes? Well now you don’t have to, with our @%$<# 10minute potatoes!” I have to ask myself, what the hell is going on? Is this a symptom of our times, have we traded in time, patience, and a connection to our food for Zip, Zap, and Serve? These commercials are everywhere and they always leave me shaking my head and with less hope for humanity than before. The reality is this magic potato product is a) filled with nasty unhealthy preservatives, b) packaged in an equal amount of plastic to a 15lb bag of raw potatoes, c) takes people out of the kitchen and a connection to cooking, d) conditions children to favour instant, obesity-encouraging nourishment likely resulting in a lifetime of similar choices, e) costs more, f), g) , h), the list goes on and on.
I kinda got off on a tangent rant there. I apologize. But it drives me totally mental! In my opinion, this is NOT progress, but again it’s subjective, maybe if I were a single parent after a long day at the office I’d really appreciate those potatoes. See, This is where I lose hope… everything is connected and even as I try to justify the need for instant food I’m asking questions, maybe the instant food isn’t that answer, maybe a shorter work day is, a workday where you can spend time with your children and cook a good meal. Then another connection arises: housing costs. Often both parents in a family have to work long hours because the cost of living has become so high, something Jane Jacobs, in her book Dark Age Ahead, indicates as a symptom of a coming dark age. Either way, for me it’s not just about potatoes, it’s about the reality we’ve built up around a central notion of progress, frankly, I don’t see progress in so much of what we do and so much of what we live for.
I’m trying to look at the big picture. I’m trying to look at things with a long-view. I completely agree with Claire when it comes to things like medical science, mechanical engineering, or physics, we’ve made huge leaps and bounds in the past one hundred and fifty years, and I agree that in some cases we have achieved true progress. The reason I hold up the progress trap sign is because I fear that if we don’t separate the true progress from the false, down the road we may find ourselves still living in a completely unsustainable world. As a result of these choices we may end up losing much of what we’ve worked so hard to create. And where would that leave us?
As we come down the mountain, someone asks the time, Claire pulls her cell from her bag, no signal and therefore no clock. Looking at her with a wry smile I have only one word, “Progress”.
peace,
d